News
About Natalia
Games
Our Team
Articles
Gallery
Chess Links
Play Chess
Pogonina's Chess Shop
Advertise
Contact Us

Highlights

 Follow Natalia on Twitter:

http://www.pogonina.com/images//nat%20twit.jpg

 
Please help Natalia promote chess by making a donation:



 

Link to Pogonina.com

Play chess at ChessOk

365Chess.com Biggest Online Chess Games Database





Check qyto.jp for Japanese bitcoin casinos.

Casivo compares the best new slot sites in the UK, click here to see the updated list.

Visit No Rules Casino for the best sites, bonuses and UK offers

Here you can find Swedish sites without license, Spelkonto utan licens.

Check out this list of new casinos in Finland

Find new casinos at the brand new Online Casinos XYZ site with reviews and ratings of the best gambling sites for UK players.

Play the popular King Kong Cash slot machine at Slot Strike, the new slot site for UK players.

Grab the chance to win big with a high RTP on the goonies slot progressive jackpot.

Goodluckmate.com - made an easier way to find Skrill casinos

Nettikasinot.media lists the best online casinos for Finnish gamblers. For more information visit: https://www.nettikasinot.media/suomalaiset-kasinot/  

Sweden is now a regulated market, which means that as a player you can only play at casinos with a license. See all regulated
casinos in Sweden by Mr casinova.

To find the best casino in Norway take look at
norske casino at CasinoPiloten.

Find the best Norwegian casinobonus at NyeCasinoNorge.org.

Get exclusive access to a
huge range of free spins & no deposit casino offers with Spin Bonus.

Try the exhilarating new 20p Roulette game.
Play it online at thecasinodb and find casinos to play for real money.

Get the best casino bonus information with Casino Gorilla.

Visit Casinomir United Kingdom for top casino sites, game guides and the best UK offers.

Chess games at Gametop

CasinoAdvisers.com For you that want to find online casino strategies, guides and a good casino bonus!

 
   ...


Polls
What's your FIDE rating?

What should Natalia do to make Pogonina.com more interesting for you?

Who is your favorite active top player?

Poker or chess: what do you like more?

What's the largest monetary chess prize you ever won?

How much time per day do you spend on chess-related activities?

Do you have a special chess mascot (pen, badge, toy, etc.)?

Which time control do you prefer for over-the-board tournaments?

The strongest women's chess team in the world is

What is the strongest national chess team in the world?

Will Magnus Carlsen's rating reach FIDE 2900?

Do you think you can become a GM?

Hikaru Nakamura: Flawless Victory of Double Standards

User Rating: / 53
PoorBest 
Written by Administrator   
Wednesday, 11 April 2012
Article Index
Hikaru Nakamura: Flawless Victory of Double Standards
Page 2

Hikaru_Nakamura_Victoria_1

Photo: FIDE.com

FIDE.com has surprised me a little: Hikaru Nakamura won an open tournament, and I have completely overlooked his event! The #1 US chess player scored a flawless 6/6 in the Canadian Grand Pacific Open. Time for congratulations?
 

A look at the final table informed me that the #6 chess grandmaster in the world has dispatched amateurs rated in the 1900+-2300+ range on his way to the top. Moreover, not a single player rated  2400 or above took part in the tournament. It is somewhat strange that the pros decided not to compete against Naka for some reason. Anyway, whatever. Maybe the noble top GM just wanted to arrange an exclusive holiday for amateurs?


As a result of his impressive performance, Nakamura gained a few rating points. Those are as precious as gold at the top level. So what? Yes, there is an exploit in the rating system - the 400 points rule.  It allows people to beat significantly lower-rated players and earn rating points as if they were rated just 400 points lower. In other words, a win against 1900 is worth the same for Nakamura as a win against a 2350, although the former is much easier to achieve. Nonetheless, such victories often prove to be Pyrrhic: by facing amateurs a top GM loses concentration and then squanders away the freshly gained points playing against his colleagues at super tournaments.


The reason why I have written this post is different. When the #1 junior chess player in the world Fabiano Caruana overtook Hikaru Nakamura on the live-rating list, Hikaru instantly made a bitter remark about his performance in Reyjkavik Open:
 

hikarurating.jpg


A quick reminder: the line-up of that tournament included such world-class players as Navara, Cheparinov, Krivoruchko, Sokolov, Hou Yifan, Gawain Jones, Hess and many other strong GMs. During the event Fabiono was challenged by five 2600+ players and scored 2 wins, 3 draws agains them. To give you a chance to compare his result with Nakamura's performance, I will provide a link. Feel the difference.
 

Right after his tweet Hikaru was asked by Natalia Pogonina to clarify his opinion:
 

questionfornaka.jpg


Obviously, Nakamura replied with his actions instead of words by crushing not just "weaker players", but relatively defenceless amateurs. Maybe he thinks that's the right approach to supporting the image of one of the world's top grandmasters.


P
.S. Mission accomplished: as of today Hikaru Nakamura has regained the #6 spot in the live-ratings and is clearly enjoying himself.
 


 Screenshot from 2700chess.com

About the author


Peter Zhdanov is an IT project manager, debate expert and author of two books on parliamentary debate, BSc in Applied Mathematics and Computer Science and final year PhD student in Sociology.


In chess Peter is a Russian candidate master, author, husband and manager of grandmaster Natalia Pogonina.

 

 





 
Bookmark and Share




Comments (11)
11. Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it on 20:59 05 2013 .
 
 
83667
Hurrah, that's what I was seeking for, what a stuff! present here at this webpage, thanks admin of this site.|
 

Write Comment
Name:
E-mail
Homepage
Title:
BBCode:Web AddressEmail AddressBold TextItalic TextUnderlined TextQuoteCodeOpen ListList ItemClose List
Comment:



Code:* Code



Last Updated ( Wednesday, 11 April 2012 )
 
< Prev   Next >