About Natalia
Our Team
Chess Links
Play Chess
Pogonina's Chess Shop
Contact Us


 Follow Natalia on Twitter:

Please help Natalia promote chess by making a donation:


Link to

Play chess at ChessOk Biggest Online Chess Games Database

Check for Japanese bitcoin casinos.

Casivo compares the best new slot sites in the UK, click here to see the updated list.

Visit No Rules Casino for the best sites, bonuses and UK offers

Here you can find Swedish sites without license, Spelkonto utan licens.

Check out this list of new casinos in Finland

Find new casinos at the brand new Online Casinos XYZ site with reviews and ratings of the best gambling sites for UK players.

Play the popular King Kong Cash slot machine at Slot Strike, the new slot site for UK players.

Grab the chance to win big with a high RTP on the goonies slot progressive jackpot. - made an easier way to find Skrill casinos lists the best online casinos for Finnish gamblers. For more information visit:  

Sweden is now a regulated market, which means that as a player you can only play at casinos with a license. See all regulated
casinos in Sweden by Mr casinova.

To find the best casino in Norway take look at
norske casino at CasinoPiloten.

Find the best Norwegian casinobonus at

Get exclusive access to a
huge range of free spins & no deposit casino offers with Spin Bonus.

Try the exhilarating new 20p Roulette game.
Play it online at thecasinodb and find casinos to play for real money.

Get the best casino bonus information with Casino Gorilla.

Visit Casinomir United Kingdom for top casino sites, game guides and the best UK offers.

Chess games at Gametop For you that want to find online casino strategies, guides and a good casino bonus!


What's your FIDE rating?

What should Natalia do to make more interesting for you?

Who is your favorite active top player?

Poker or chess: what do you like more?

What's the largest monetary chess prize you ever won?

How much time per day do you spend on chess-related activities?

Do you have a special chess mascot (pen, badge, toy, etc.)?

Which time control do you prefer for over-the-board tournaments?

The strongest women's chess team in the world is

What is the strongest national chess team in the world?

Will Magnus Carlsen's rating reach FIDE 2900?

Do you think you can become a GM?

Chess Engines' Evaluations

User Rating: / 18
Written by Administrator   
Wednesday, 25 January 2012

by Natalia Pogonina for her Tuesday column

Nowadays powerful chess engines have become routine assistants of competitive chess players. Both amateurs and professionals use them to analyze their games, prepare opening lines, evaluate certain positions, etc. Most websites that broadcast games also offer a built-in engine evaluation to make the viewing process more interesting for chess fans. Such mighty servants as chess engines are of great use, but they also pose a serious danger.

First of all, its very easy to lose ones own tactical skill if one starts following the computer lines without thinking for oneself. Secondly, quite a few players, even very strong ones, start worshipping engines and religiously trusting them. However, there are still blank spots in the evaluation mechanisms of the programs, so even at a large depth the first line of a program is not necessarily the best move.  Also, when playing humans we have to try to pose as much difficulties before the opponent as possible, place them under psychological pressure. Meanwhile, computers dont know such things, and for them a king vs king position is evaluated the same as an insanely complicated draw that can be reached by making 20 one-and-only moves in a row.

Computer engines evaluate positions and offer an aggregate figure to show who is ahead. The number means how much better one side is in terms of material. Of course, in most positions material is not the only factor to consider, so the figure is derived by carefully weighing the tactical variations and positional factors.

Equality: =, from 0 to 0.26

Small advantage for White: +/=, over 0.27 and up to 0.7

Serious advantage for White: +/- over 0.7

Decisive advantage for White: +-, over 1.5

The signs for Black are similar (=, =/+, -/+, -+). A sign is used to show that Black is ahead. E.g. a -0.8 evaluation means that Black has a serious advantage that is equal to about 0.8 of a pawn.

In some theoretically drawn positions the engines might still be saying that one side is ahead. Therefore, in endgames one should be especially careful when analyzing. The only exception is the endgame (Nalimov) tablebases (6-men are available online; 7-men are harder to find; creation of 32-men would mean that chess is solved). Using those one can instantly find the mathematical evaluation of the position: draw or a win for one of the sides.

Here is an example from the recently played Karjakin vs Topalov game, round 7 of Tata Steel Chess tournament:

The strong sides of chess engines are calculation and defense. They can also come up with unexpected and bizarre-looking ideas in certain positions. The weaknesses (if we can say so about players rated well over 3000) are positional evaluation and long-term planning. Quite often a chess engine would be saying that one side is better for a series of moves, and then all of a sudden treacherously change the evaluation for the opposite.

I use chess engines to check all my games and openings. However, the final decision belongs to me. This is especially true for positions with a few more or less equal options available. In such cases its very important to understand the idea/plan behind each of the moves. The difference might become obvious only a couple of moves later. In such situations chess engines are of no use, so you should either rely on your own brain, or check out leading players games to make a choice. Dont be afraid to make a move that is not deemed to be the best by the engine.


Post-mortem: Robert Huebner and Natalia Pogonina. Photo by Martin Chrz

The instructive example of the above-mentioned principles will be my first game against former world #3 Robert Huebner from the Snowdrops vs Oldhands match (the second game was drawn as well). Most of the time the engine I have been using to analyze was claiming that the position is equal. However, by doing so it was neglecting some important features of the position. For example, after 20dc the computer still says the evaluation is close to 0, but a qualified human would tell you that White is better. Black is obliged to defend passively, while White has some plans associated with pushing the kingside pawns. Therefore, in human terms its a position for two results: either White will win, or the game will be drawn. Maybe with strong play the position is indeed drawish, but Black is the only side at risk.


Therefore, if you prepare for the game only by memorizing chess engines moves and evaluations, at some point you will get in trouble. Always try to understand the ideas behind moves and make sure you understand why the position is evaluated as it is. For us, humans, intuition and experience are more important than brute force calculation. A chess engine is a great assistant, but it can never substitute for using ones own brain in an over-the-board game.

Bookmark and Share

Comments (2)
1. Written by This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it on 13:45 25 2012 .
Pero que bien hablas y que guapa eres!
2. Written by Andrey on 07:18 27 2012 .
I cannot agree more with the last sentence.  
IMHO, the most important thing about computer evaluations hides in the fact that some number, let's say +0.34, represents the static evaluation of some "final position". 
And this number has won every competition inside the engine to get to the top and become accounted as evaluation of initial position.  
Although minimax or negamax are perfect search algorithms (applied to the whole game from starting position, either algorithm will give you the evaluation of the game), search horizon affects every practical chess engine and sometimes these essentially static evaluations can be very skewed.

Write Comment
BBCode:Web AddressEmail AddressBold TextItalic TextUnderlined TextQuoteCodeOpen ListList ItemClose List

Code:* Code

Last Updated ( Wednesday, 25 January 2012 )
< Prev   Next >